☀ New York | Saturday November 21, 2026 | Sign In
⚡ TRENDING NOW

Employers advised to seek counsel before suspending staff

Employers advised to seek counsel before suspending staff - employee suspension
Small businesses often face financial exposure when a staff member is accused of a crime.

When a staff member is accused of a crime, the shock can ripple through a small business, raising worries about workplace safety, customer perception and financial exposure.

Owners often feel pressure to act quickly, sometimes moving straight to dismissal. A rushed decision, however, can jeopardize a later employment tribunal and even interfere with a police probe.

Before any suspension, the first step is to review the employee’s contract. If the agreement does not contain an explicit right to suspend, the employer should seek legal advice before proceeding.

Whichever route you take, explain it to the employee in writing and keep a record of your reasons.

In serious cases, bringing in an independent criminal lawyer to run the investigation can add credibility. Such counsel can interview witnesses, preserve evidence and ensure the process meets investigatory standards.

Deciding Whether to Suspend

Suspension can shield coworkers and prevent tampering with evidence, but it is not intended as a punishment. It should normally be on full pay and last only as long as necessary.

If the contract lacks a suspension clause, the employer must tread carefully and obtain specialist advice. Acting without that basis may expose the business to claims of unfair treatment.

ACAS guidance makes clear that employers do not usually have to wait for a criminal case to conclude before making their own decision. The existence of a police investigation or a charge alone is not automatically grounds for dismissal.

The criminal court must be convinced of guilt, while an employer needs only a reasonable belief, based on a reasonable investigation, that misconduct occurred. Consequently, a person acquitted in court could still be lawfully dismissed, and someone never charged could still face disciplinary action.

Employees are generally expected to cooperate with internal inquiries, but when a criminal investigation is underway they may be advised by their own lawyer to remain silent to avoid prejudicing the police case.

Orwins partners Stephanie Roe and Howard Lewis-Nunn note that aligning criminal and employment counsel at the outset minimizes the chance of procedural missteps and strengthens the evidential foundation for any subsequent legal action. By following a fair procedure, including giving the employee a reasonable opportunity to respond to any disciplinary allegations, businesses can handle these complex situations effectively and make informed decisions about the employee’s future with the company.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *